Sell Us Your Cards

What We Generally Buy

We actively purchase a wide range of trading and sports cards, with a focus on quality and condition.

Here's a breakdown of what we're currently buying:

Pokémon TCG

  • Preferred: Graded slabs (PSA, BGS, CGC, etc.)
  • Ungraded slabs/raw cards: Accepted with proper photo verification or via a quick virtual meeting for authentication

Sports Cards (We buy in this order of preference)

  • Baseball
  • Basketball
  • Football

Other sports

Hockey, soccer, etc, are considered, however, will require a virtual meeting for verification.

Other Trading Card Games

  • Yu-Gi-Oh!
  • Magic: The Gathering

We buy singles, sealed product, collections, and bulk lots. Condition and authenticity are key — graded cards are ideal, but we evaluate strong raw cards as well.

Have cards you're looking to sell?

Contact us at: sales@blackmarketbookie.com

We respond quickly and provide fair offers with fast payment options.

PAYMENT OPTIONS 

Payment Policy – Secure Invoices Only

For your safety and ours, we only send and accept payments through official, secure invoices on the following platforms:

  • PayPal – Payments must be sent via a PayPal Goods & Services Invoice
  • Venmo – Payments must be sent via a Venmo Business Invoice

We never request or accept:

  • Friends & Family transfers
  • Direct bank wires
  • Cash App, Zelle, or other unsecured methods for initial payments

This policy protects both parties by providing transaction records, buyer/seller protection where available, and full transparency.

Thank you for helping us keep transactions safe and secure!